Back to the Rays Report

Roger Mooney

Roger Mooney covers the Tampa Bay Rays for The Tampa Tribune, TBO.com and News Channel 8. He has covered the Rays since their first season in 1998, including 11 years for the Bradenton Herald. Roger has also covered Florida, South Florida and Florida State football, the Bucs and the Lightning.

 @RMooneyTrib
 TBO_Rays
Send us your questions

More Links:

• Schedule/Results
• Player Stats
• Team Stats

Most Recent Entries

• Rays-BoSox in rain delay
• Davis named new girls basketball coach at Jefferson
• Collect call: 2013 Leaf Draft football
• Brooks-DeBartolo hires new girls basketball coach
• Rays 2 BoSox: Myers batting 6th, Longo back at 3B for Game 1
• Familiarity breeds confidence for Bucs
• Collect call: 2013 Bowman football
• Rays’ Myers is Bowman’s fifth lucky redemption
• Basketball showcase tonight at Berkeley Prep
• Archer, Odorizzi for doubleheader in Boston means lots of starts by rookies on this trip
• Gaither QB commits to FIU
• Gaither QB commits to FIU
• Rays v KC: Cobb tries to right the ship, Johnson dropped in the order
• Collect call: 2013 Topps Archives baseball
• Rays v KC: Moore tries to rebound

Monthly Archives

• June 2013
• May 2013
• April 2013
• March 2013
• February 2013
• January 2013

One ballot: Why Price over Hernandez

Posted Nov 18, 2010 by Tribune Sports

Updated Nov 18, 2010 at 09:42 PM

By TONY FABRIZIO
As you probably know by now, Seattle ace Felix Hernandez today won the AL Cy Young Award easily over Tampa Bay’s David Price and New York’s CC Sabathia. Boston’s Jon Lester finished third and Los Angeles’ Jered Weaver fourth.

Hernandez, who was 13-12 with a league-best 2.27 ERA, received 21 of the 28 first-place votes and 167 points in balloting by the Baseball Writers’ Association of America. Price (19-6, 2.72) received 111 points and four first-place votes and Sabathia (21-7, 3.18) three first-place votes and 102 points.

Two BBWAA from each league city participated, and I had one of the ballots. I voted Price first, Hernandez second and Sabathia third.

I don’t think there was a blatantly right or wrong answer among Price, Hernandez and Sabathia for first place. I gave the edge to Price because I thought he had the best combination of wins, winning percentage, ERA and a wide variety of other measurables when also factoring in the significance of his contributions.

Price went 10-2 in what I still think is the toughest division in the American League. He pitched in high-leverage games throughout the year. When the Rays were battling the Yankees neck-and-neck for the AL East pennant in September, he went 4-0 with a 1.64 ERA. The Rays won his final six regular season starts.

After July 18, the Rays lost only twice in regular-season games Price started, and in those two games, the Rays scored a combined two runs. Opposing batters hit .172 against Price after Sept. 1.

Price didn’t pitch against Hernandez (the Rays didn’t face him), but he matched up against Sabathia twice. The Rays won both games. Both were played in September, and in one, a 1-0 Tampa Bay win on Sept. 13, Price held the Yankees to three hits over eight innings.

Going by stats alone, Hernandez wins hands-down. He had dominating numbers for a punchless team. He was also very good against the AL East, although he was only 3-6 in his own division.

King Felix is a deserving Cy Young Award winner. But when I filled out my ballot after the final regular-season game, I believed the ace on the AL East champions’ staff was the most deserving.