Posted by  Dustin Keene, Tampa, FL on 10/13  at  08:23 PM

Bet the owners and Melrose wish they had a time machine to go back a few months and make the defense look something like this…

Dan Boyle - Alexandre Picard
Mike Lundin - Matt Smaby
Filip Kuba - Brad Lukowich

Paul Ranger and Shane O’Brien as alts

Posted by  Kevin Escribano, Renton, WA on 10/13  at  07:32 PM

What about Matt Smaby?  Give him a chance before signing Malik!

Posted by  Chris C, Lakeland on 10/13  at  05:01 PM

They should have thought about the defense in JULY..who is going to give up a top defenseman? O ya we did when we traded Dan Boyle

Posted by  Tank, Orlando on 10/13  at  04:17 PM

I dont understand why the Lightning do not ask the Sharks to recall Kyle McLaren.  His salary is 7.5 MM over three years, so on recall waivers we pay half of the remaining contract, so that would work out to 1.25 MM a year.  I would think that he is worth the extra 250k a year over Marek Malik.  McLaren is/was considered the best hip checker in the game and he has a nasty streak that Melrose would love… Any reason why Lawton is not interested?

Posted by  BillSmith, Central FL on 10/13  at  04:03 PM

Heward is the logical choice. He will have to clear waivers, and according to the NHLPA website his cap hit is $475,000 (I must have overlooked him before, my bad).

Heward is a servicable defensman along the lines of Pratt, Lukowich or Neckar. He is 37 which works against him here in the youth movement.

Malik is a stay at homer and may be able to add a dimension not currently on the roster. What we have now is not working. Malik can not make us any worse than we are now. Ranger’s return will help also.

Posted by  Mike Joyce, Bangkok, Thailand on 10/13  at  03:03 PM

Bill,

I can see Niskala going, but if the get Ranger back and sign Malik, they will still have one extra defender.  Do you think Heward might be the other one to go to Norfolk.

I sure hope that we get Malik.  Maybe that way, the opposition won’t be able to take runs at the goalie, like they did Saturday night.

Posted by  BillSmith, Central FL on 10/13  at  02:53 PM

Mike,

My guess is Niskala goes to Norfolk. He is getting the fewest minutes so far on defense and he dosen’t have to clear waivers and I think he has a two way contract and he is the lowest paid defenseman on the current roster.

Posted by  BillSmith, Central FL on 10/13  at  02:41 PM

He may bring some punishing toughness our blue line needs. He is big and experienced. Lets keep our fingers crossed and hope this tweek works.

Posted by  Mike Joyce, Bangkok, Thailand on 10/13  at  02:34 PM

Erik,

With Ranger returning in the near future, who do you suppose will be shipped to Norfolk?