Latest News Reports

TBO.com > Life

The Dirt: Penny Carnathan and Kim Franke-Folstad
Email Us: Penny | Kim

The debate has been sowed—time for a coup against the national flower


  George Ball, chair of the Burpee seed company, has an Independence Day proposition: Change our national flower from the rose to the sunflower.
 
Roses, he argues on his blog, are nearly all immigrants (let’s just disregard that whole melting pot thing, George). He says they seem “strikingly out of place amid Independence Day’s blaze of red, white and blue.” Red roses? That clashes? 

  And, he says, they’d never, ever feel comfortable at a good old-fashioned beer-swilling, flip-floppin’ July 4th picnic.

I beg to differ. I can totally see a rose at this picnic.

photo

  I have problems with George’s logic, but I do think we can do better than the rose. Roses say love, and love and revolution mix best in a John Jakes novel. I love sunflowers, but they’re not the answer. Yes, they’re cheerful, optimistic and big cash cows – all reflective of our red-white-and-blue values. But it seems as soon as they bloom, they nod their big heads like heroin addicts and then crash in a stupor.

  Sure that’s a societal trait, but one we want to celebrate?

  How about the dandelion, instead?

photo

  Oh yeah, I hear the Yanks: “They’re weeds!” But not if you subscribe to the theory that weeds are just flowers growing where they’re not invited. I, for one, would love those bright yellow blooms in my “lawn.” 

  As for symbolism, is it not the American way to pop up where we’re not welcome? When they turn to fuzz balls, we make a wish and blow. I do believe that’s horti-talk for “seeking the American dream.”

  OK, I know dandelions will splat alongside Ben Franklin’s bid for the turkey as national bird. So I’m officially casting my ballot for the apple blossom.

photo

  It’s beautiful, it fruits, and if you know someone who bakes, it becomes apple pie. The whole “American as apple pie” is, of course, a misnomer. But it did come from the mother country and it’s fun to think we told England, “You go. The pie stays.”

After much deliberation, Kim is nominating the daisy.

photo

Like Americans, it respects the pursuit of happiness – it loves full sun and rich soil, she says. But also like Americans, it will tolerate poor conditions without withering.

The daisy is simple but beautiful, and versatile. You can grow it in almost any garden, and it’s a staple for just about any bouquet. You can grow your own from seed or adopt a plant and bring it home knowing it will almost always thrive.

  Anyone have a better idea? I’m sure George is just itching for us to weigh in.

 

Send Us Your Comments

Posted by  Penny L. Carnathan,  on 07/06  at  03:53 PM

No Becca, the ones I sowed straight into the ground outside are doing great ... well, except for the one that promptly keeled over after blooming. It was the ones I started inside that struggled, although the survivors are now little beauties.
  The problem is, I’m just a perennial girl. Good thing I’m not living in an annuals world! They’ll always break your heart eventually.


Posted by  Becca,  on 07/06  at  03:35 PM

I considered the apple blossom too, but disregarded it for the same reasons.
And Penny - starting the seeds outside for sunflowers? THAT’S why they failed. Sunflowers have broken my heart too many times.


Posted by  Penny L. Carnathan,  on 07/04  at  03:43 PM

There is a national everything! I’m sure if we look hard enough, we’ll find a national bug and a national fertlizer, too.
  I have a soft spot (no pun!) for apples because I’m from Vermont. Apple orchards all over the place and nothing as sweet as a fresh McIntosh (except maybe maple syrup.) I’m not so into daisies for no good reason.
  Janna, most of my first batch of sunflowers are in bloom and gorgeous! One mammoth bloomed and then fell over the next day. One is very shy—looks at the ground all the time.  The best mammoths are growing in the worst dirt. 
  For the record sunflower growers, the plants from seeds started outside were much hardier and grew faster than those started in cups indoors.


Posted by  Susan Gillespie,  on 07/04  at  11:32 AM

Hmm—-so many choices, really, for national flower. Like the rest I did not even know the rose was our national flower. But I can see how it would appeal to everyone. Since all of mine made it through the freezes they are now my garden fave.
The apple blossom truly is beautiful but since we can’t grow it here how can it be called “national”.
I’m leaning towards Kim’s choice of daisies. Reliable, dependable, national—-Daisies.
But I am open to that Tuscany sunflower trip.


Posted by  Janna,  on 07/04  at  09:01 AM

I’m with Becca in not knowing until this blog that the rose is the national flower. I have never had good luck growing them! As for dandelions,if that or any weed has a pretty bloom, it stays in my yard. I love sunflowers, but they are very short lived. By the way, Penny - how are yours doing?


Posted by  Penny L. Carnathan,  on 07/02  at  05:21 PM

I do believe that strikes the fatal blow for sunflowers as national flower! (For us anyway.) I’m adding Tuscany to my to-do list.


Posted by  RickBrown,  on 07/02  at  05:16 PM

Everytime I see sunflowers I think of the rolling hills of Tuscany. That is where all those calendar and screensaver images come from. I would love to go to Tuscany and see fields of what I think of as Italy’s national flower in full bloom. We have ceramics from Tuscany adorned with sunflowers. It just seems to be theirs and they truly do sunflowers justice.


Posted by  Penny L. Carnathan,  on 07/02  at  04:40 PM

Apparently (according to George’s blog) the rose became our official flower back in the ‘80s, but people had been pushing for one for years and years.
The daisy is a good choice. Poor dandelion is so maligned.


Posted by  Becca,  on 07/02  at  02:56 PM

I’m in full support of the non-rose idea, I honestly didn’t even know it was our national flower until I read this. With the premise of the daffodil pulling a close second, my vote goes to the daisy. I really wouldn’t enjoy a national flower that had a nickname of a weed, but it does still hold up what I think it is to be american!


Page 1 of 1 pages

Advertisement

Send Us Your Comments
Terms & Conditions

* Comments Must Include Full Name And Location


Login | Register

Please Register or Login to post comments.


Write a letter to the editor | Subscribe and get two weeks free | Place an Ad Online

Site Tools

RSS Feeds:
XML Feed for this channel
All feeds/RSS FAQ


On Twitter:
@TheDirtTBO
Your Questions:

Have a gardening question? Send it to Penny and Kim, and they may answer it in The Dirt.

Planting Guide:

Check out our month-by-month tips of what to do and plant:

Bay Area Nurseries:

We dug through our archives and asked nurseries for info
to build this growing guide.

At Home Headlines:
About Us:

Kim's a Want It Now (WIN): Everything pretty, everything now.

Penny's a Nurture And Hold (NAH): Nah, I won't pull that out yet, it's still got a green shoot.

Kim will resort to full-spectrum insecticides in desperate situations, and believes it's her duty and right to buy new plants every weekend.

Penny likes dragonflies, lady bugs and new stuff only after weeding, pruning and fertilizing.

Both advocate Plant Choice (SOMEthing besides crotons. Please!), lots of color and low maintenance.

We don't agree on everything, but we're smart enough to learn from each other - and from you.


ADVERTISEMENT

Advertise With Us:
Online | In Print | Broadcast